Pale Ale Showdown: Sierra Nevada vs Deschutes

Deschutes Mirror Pond Pale Ale

 vs.

Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

These two Pale Ales are common sights in North Cal bars, restaurants, and stores. Sierra Nevada tends to have a wider distribution than Mirror Pond. If you're in the mood for a very drinkable, straightforward beer, Pale Ales are usually the right choice. So what's the right choice between two of the most popular West Coast Pale Ales?

Beer advocate gives Sierra Nevada an average rating of 4.09 out of 5, with 2,483 reviews and a grade of A- from both the review average and "The Bros"(the the owners and operators). Mirror Pond has an average rating of 3.93 out of 5, with 635 reviews and a grade of B+ from the review, but an A from The Bros. 

From the disparity in reviews we can tell Sierra Nevada is more wide spread. However, the Bros who operate the site and publish Beer Advocate magazine, give Mirror Pond a slight advantage.

Rate Beer gives Sierra Nevada a 3.62 out of 5 and gives Mirror Pond a 3.46.

While Sierra Nevada seems to have a slight edge in reviews, The Blog unanimously felt that Mirror Pond is the superior brew. We thought Mirror Pond has a better balance of malt and hops with smoother drinkability. We would choose Mirror Pond over Sierra Nevada anyday.

Sierra Nevada has some amazing beers. But to us Sierra Nevada Pale Ale is the "testing the water" beer for the folks that love their Coors or Bud. Mirror Pond is slightly more obscure outside the West Coast, but is by far the better choice for a drinkable, enjoyable Pale Ale.

What's your opinion?